5. The Reciter Repeating his Prayer

Prayed Behind One Who Cannot Re The meaning of Ummee is one prayer is poor regardless ofwhich part o be.2 According to the Shaafi'ees and Han one who cannot recite the whole ofal-Faa out a word or letter, or makes grammatica the meaning is altered.3 There is no doubt that the one w more privileged than the one who cann case of leading prayer. It is obligatory th 1 al-Mubda (2/65). 2 Refer toal-Mutla' (pg. 10), and ash-Sharh as-Saghee 3 Refer toal-Mughnee (2/195-197) and al-Majmoo' (4 CungregationalPrayer can recite well be allowed to lead the Prophet (peace be upon him) said, f/j " 0....... ill\ ut:SJ ", ~"·i ": ,. ,.. ,.,. r-"")~ ir "Let the most proficient of the people Allah lead them [in prayer]."! But if someone whose recitatio of the prayer was poor were to lead the the ruling of the prayer of those who p respect to its validity and having to differed about this, expressing four opin First Opinion: The prayer is no whoever has been led has to repeat t opinion of Abu Haneefah, Maalik, ash-S Second Opinion: Praying beh Since it is permissible, it is not nec prayer. Third Opinion: It is permissible Quraan to pray behind one who canno those prayers that are prayed silently Fourth Opinion: If the one who correctly was to lead those who cannot prayer is valid. The Strongest Opinion: The stro fourth opinion but some conditions need

6.The One Who Has Intended an Repeating his Prayer Because He Who Had Intended an Optio There are three possible situations: (1) The follower and Imaam agreement inwardly and outwardly; (2) The follower and Imaam outwardly but not inwardly, such as obligatory prayer behind one who i prayer; (3) The follower and Imaam inwardly only. The scholars have differed on these issues. The First Opinion: It is obligatory for the Imaam and follower to agree in both intention and outward action. The Second Opinion: It is permissible for the Imaam and follower to differ in both. The Strongest Opinion: It is obligatory that the Imaam and follower agree in the outward matters but not the inward.