Content Guidelines

Islam.wiki follows strict editorial and theological guidelines to maintain accuracy and trustworthiness. Every contributor, regardless of trust level, is expected to follow these guidelines. Repeated or serious violations result in account suspension.

Source Requirements

We accept content sourced from: the Quran (with ayah reference), authentic Hadith collections (with collection, book, and number), classical scholarly works (with author, title, and edition if possible), and reputable modern scholarship where it aligns with classical methodology. We do not accept content from anonymous sources, non-peer-reviewed blogs, or websites without traceable scholarly credentials. When in doubt, cite the primary source rather than a secondary commentary.

Hadith Grading

Only hadith graded as sahih (authentic) or hasan (good) should be cited as evidence for religious rulings. Da'if (weak) hadith may be mentioned for context but must be labeled as such. Fabricated (mawdu') hadith must never be presented as valid. If you are uncertain of a hadith's grading, do not include it — flag the page instead and note that verification is needed.

Theological Framework

We follow the methodology of Ahl us-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah. All four madhabs — Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali — are presented equally. In matters of aqeedah, we primarily follow the Athari creed while accepting Ash'ari and Maturidi as legitimate positions within Sunni Islam. Positions that contradict the consensus of Ahl us-Sunnah — such as those of the Mu'tazila, Khawarij, or modern heterodox movements — are described objectively where historically relevant but are not presented as valid Islamic positions.

Groups and Sects

When writing about religious groups, use neutral and accurate language. Describe positions as classical scholars described them. Do not use inflammatory language. Nation of Islam and Ahmadiyya are not considered Muslim groups by the consensus of mainstream Islamic scholarship and should be described accordingly. Shia Islam is treated as a separate tradition with its own complex history; content about Shia beliefs should describe them accurately without endorsing or condemning. For Sufi orders, evaluate each on its merits — practices grounded in Quran and Sunnah are noted positively; innovations not supported by evidence are noted as such.

Tone and Language

All content should be written in an academic, informative tone. Avoid polemics, sectarian attacks, or political commentary. When scholars disagree, present the disagreement fairly and cite all major positions. Islam.wiki is not a platform for fatawa or personal religious advice — direct readers to qualified scholars for personal religious questions. Write for a global audience: avoid cultural assumptions, explain Arabic terms on first use, and always provide transliterations alongside Arabic text.