Loading...
Loading...
Chapter 27 of 1481 min read
سيرة علي بن أبي طالب — الجزء 27
he accused the Messenger of Allah (@) of not knowing what he was saying, as he said "he is delirious," and he did not comply with what the Prophet (g) wanted, and he said "you have the Book of Allah" and "the Book of Allah is sufficient for us", the response to that is that the first claim, which is that 'Umar (&) accused the Messenger of Allah of being delirious and not aware of what he was saying is false, because this phrase, "is he delirious?" is not proven to be the words of 'Umar (4) in the fxst place. Rather these are the words of one of the people who were present, but the reports narrated in Bukhari and Muslim do not specify who said it.